Two modest clapboard homes across a quiet winter lawn with a short curving walkway and bare trees in the Shepherdstown area.

Reading Shepherdstown's 25443 Market This Winter

In the three months ending October 2026, the median sale price in ZIP 25443 was $490,499. Only 25 homes sold in that window. Jefferson County's median sold price for October 2026 was $400,000, according to Bright MLS's October report for the Maryland and West Virginia panhandle. The two figures cover slightly different windows, and the ZIP number blends a small historic town with a much larger area of subdivisions and rural land around it. On top of that, the town has a short record of adding planned neighborhoods. The ZIP's listing count shrank from a year earlier, while the county's inventory grew across the fall.

That affects what you can buy, how quickly the choices change, and which upcoming projects matter to a search here.

Two neighborhoods under the 2007 ordinance

The Town of Shepherdstown adopted its Planned Unit Development ordinance in October 2007. The Town's April 2026 newsletter says the Shepherd Village and Sage Place neighborhoods, approved in 2016, are "the first and only developments completed under the Town's PUD ordinance."

Shepherd Village is a 30-home cohousing community on a 19-acre tract inside Shepherdstown. Its own community site says each home has a small yard and a 1/30 share of the common property, which includes about seven acres of forest. The site also puts the neighborhood a four-block walk from downtown and Shepherd University. The Shepherdstown Chronicle reported in June 2019 that all 30 units were finished on land off East German Street, with a few buildable lots still left at neighboring Sage Place Commons at the time.

The same newsletter notes that the Town's ordinance was modeled entirely on one the City of Morgantown wrote more than 25 years ago, and that the Town Council and Planning Commission are now looking at how to update it. One possible addition to town is still pending. In February 2026, Observer WV reported that the Council unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to annex about 4.7 acres on River Road. The Council held off on a second reading until further research, including a review of the PUD ordinance, and set no timeline.

For a buyer focused on the historic core around German Street, the newest planned neighborhoods in town are Shepherd Village and Sage Place, both approved a decade ago. Expect a short list of options there.

The neighborhoods that share the ZIP

Much of 25443 lies beyond the walkable center. Tollhouse Woods is a 69-home single-family subdivision south of Shepherdstown, across from Morgan's Grove Park. Observer WV reported in 2023 that the project was approved in 2005, but serious clearing and grading on the site did not start until 2021.

The Cress Creek sections are another part of the ZIP. The North Hills association lists Fernbank at Cress Creek, Cress Creek, Meadow Ridge, South Hills and North Hills as related neighborhoods. North Hills is the last section of Cress Creek, and its unit owners' association dates from 2021. Deerfield Village has an active property owners' association for its Shepherdstown community. On the river, Shepherds Cove off Swift River Way is a 19-lot community with private river access and shared amenities.

A Shepherdstown mailing address can mean a house four blocks from German Street, a lot in a Cress Creek section, a newer home across from Morgan's Grove Park, or a lot near the Potomac. Each has its own association arrangement, lot pattern and drive into town. The ZIP median mixes all of them together.

The fall numbers point in opposite directions

In ZIP 25443, 57 homes were listed at some point during the three months ending October 2026. That is 28.7% fewer than in the same period a year earlier. In Jefferson County, Bright MLS counted 279 active listings in August, 284 in September and 311 in October 2026. Over those three months, months of supply rose from 2.15 to 2.18 to 2.73. County closed sales also fell, to 89 in October 2026, down 33.1% from October 2025.

So while the county is gaining inventory heading into winter, the Shepherdstown ZIP has less to choose from than it did a year ago. Someone shopping across the eastern panhandle in November has more listings in the county overall and fewer in 25443.

Prices split sharply by property type. In the three months ending October 2026, single-family homes in 25443 sold for a median $498,787 across 20 sales. Townhouses sold for a median $344,913, but that figure comes from only five sales. The ZIP median was down 3.0% from the same window a year earlier. With 25 sales in a quarter, a few closings at either end of the range can shift that number. The price per square foot, $195.93 for the same period, gives a steadier comparison when you look at individual homes.

A path toward Morgan's Grove, and a study downtown

The biggest project now on the calendar at the edge of town will change how the Morgan's Grove side of the ZIP connects to downtown. The Town announced on November 5, 2026 that construction would begin on a five-foot-wide sidewalk along the east side of Duke Street/Kearneysville Pike. It will run from Minden Street, near Shepherdstown Middle School, south toward Morgan's Grove Park. The project dates to 2014, and the West Virginia Division of Highways is managing it with contractor SQP Construction Group. Observer WV's November 12 Shepherdstown Snapshot reported that the work was set to start November 16 at the Morgan's Grove end and moving toward town, with completion scheduled for July 2027. Tollhouse Woods sits across from Morgan's Grove Park, at the far end of that path.

Downtown, Experience Shepherdstown, the nonprofit behind First Friday and the Holiday Kickoff and Tree Lighting, is coordinating a retail market study expected in January 2027.

Neither project adds homes. The path matters most to a buyer weighing a house near Morgan's Grove against one closer to German Street, because the two are scheduled to be linked on foot by July 2027.

How this shapes a search in 25443

If you are comparing this ZIP with Charles Town, Harpers Ferry or Martinsburg, compare at the neighborhood level. A Cress Creek section, Tollhouse Woods and a house near Shepherd University are three different markets that share a ZIP code, and the $490,499 median describes none of them on its own.

For sellers, a ZIP listing count down 28.7% from a year ago, set against a rising county inventory, is the backdrop for setting a price this winter. Our Shepherdstown neighborhood page keeps the local picture in one place.

A few quick answers

Where is Tollhouse Woods? It is south of Shepherdstown, across from Morgan's Grove Park, and was planned as 69 single-family homes.

When will the Route 480 path to Morgan's Grove Park be finished? Completion is scheduled for July 2027. Work begins at the park end and moves toward Minden Street.

Is the River Road annexation final? No. The first reading passed in February 2026, and the Council has set no timeline for a second reading.

If you own a home in Shepherdstown or in one of the neighborhoods that share its ZIP, the sales that matter for your price are the few nearby, not the county median. The Legacy Team can show you where your street fits in this winter's 25443 market. Get a Free Home Valuation and we will compare your home with the sales that actually match it.

Reach out To Us Today for A Free Consultation

Follow Me on Instagram